Almost every wrong conclusion about a mix comes from comparing two things at different volumes. Louder sounds better. That is not a flaw in your ears, it is how hearing works, and it means any comparison made at mismatched levels is worthless.
This matters especially when judging a tuning change, because a retuned mix is often subtly quieter or brighter at the same fader position.
Why loudness wins over everything
Human hearing is more sensitive to level than to almost any other property of a sound. Studies of audio quality consistently show that listeners reliably prefer the louder of two versions even when they are otherwise identical. The preference is strong enough to swamp real differences in frequency response, stereo width, or tuning.
So if you turn up a 432Hz version and decide you prefer it, you have learned almost nothing about the tuning. You have measured your own response to volume.
How to match properly
There are three levels of rigour here. Use the first that answers your question.
Level matching by ear
Put both versions on the same bus, bypass one, and adjust gain until switching back and forth feels like nothing is happening. This is the fastest method and adequate for most judgements.
Level matching with a meter
A loudness meter reading integrated LUFS is the standard measure of perceived loudness of a whole piece. Print both versions, measure them, and match the readings within about 0.1 LU. This is the professional method and it is well worth learning.
On-axis reference
The most rigorous approach. Play a calibration tone at a known level before switching between versions, and match the programme to that tone. This removes the listener's own volume drift, which is real and larger than most differences people are trying to detect.
The loudness trap in tuning comparisons
A retuned mix is often not identical in level, because shifting frequencies moves energy between bands. Comparing 440Hz and 432Hz at matched fader positions therefore risks a false conclusion in either direction.
With 432Hz MASTER or RASTA 528Hz, the simplest correction is to check the output level after engaging the plugin and trim the output to match. Then listen.
A comparison routine that works
Normalise both versions to the same integrated loudness, or match them by ear on a single bus.
Switch using a gap of a second or two, rather than an instant toggle. Instant switching is hard to judge.
Listen to the second half of the track as well as the first. Fatigue makes early judgements unreliable.
Decide on the third or fourth listen. The first one tells you nothing.
A note on meters
Meters measure level, not quality. They can confirm that two versions are equally loud, and that is genuinely useful. They cannot tell you which sounds better, and a perfectly matched pair of versions can still be two very different mixes.
Use the meter to remove the variable, then trust your ears on what remains.
Compare the tuning, not the volume
432Hz MASTER and RASTA 528Hz preserve level relationships, so a fair matched-loudness comparison is straightforward.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the louder mix always sound better?
Hearing is more sensitive to level than to almost any other property. Listeners reliably prefer the louder of two otherwise identical mixes, which is why any comparison must start with matched loudness.
How do you A/B match loudness in a DAW?
Route both versions to the same bus and bypass between them, adjusting gain until switching feels like nothing changes. For more rigour, print both and match integrated LUFS within about 0.1 LU.
What is LUFS?
Loudness Units Full Scale, a measure of perceived loudness across a whole piece rather than a single moment. It is the current standard for comparing programme loudness.
Does 432Hz sound better than 440Hz?
Only you can answer that, and only through a matched-loudness comparison. Many producers prefer 432Hz once the level difference is removed, but the honest test requires equal loudness on both sides.